Hulley Enterprises Limited (Cyprus) v. Russia

You are not logged in. If you are a subscriber, please Login to view additional case details. If you are not a subscriber, you can contact us for a rate quote at subscribe@iareporter.com. Alternatively, you can sign up to receive free email headlines here.

Case Details

Year of Filing: 2005

Claimant(s): Hulley Enterprises Limited (Cyprus)

Respondent(s): Russian Federation

Arbitral Rules: UNCITRAL and/or Ad-Hoc

Legal Instrument: Treaty

Treaty: Energy Charter Treaty

Administrative Case Number: PCA Case No. AA226

Arbitral Tribunal

You are not logged in.

You are not logged in.

You are not logged in.

You are not logged in.

You are not logged in.

You are not logged in.

You are not logged in.

You are not logged in.

You are not logged in.

Major Developments

Key Decision:

You are not logged in.

Counsel

Counsel for Claimant:

You are not logged in.

Counsel for Respondent:

You are not logged in.

UPDATED: Against backdrop of threatened BIT arbitration, Paris Court of Appeal confirms release of Russian space agency assets that had been frozen by Yukos claimants Jun 27, 2017

Russian space agency threatens BIT arbitration against France following moves to enforce Yukos award – dispute echoes Kaliningrad BIT claim against Lithuania Oct 24, 2016

ANALYSIS: As domestic courts second-guess arbitral verdicts in past Yukos cases, three more tribunals are currently assessing whether they have jurisdiction over Russia under ECT Apr 25, 2016

Dutch court sets aside US$50 billion Yukos award, criticising tribunal for accepting provisional application of Energy Charter Treaty to Russia Apr 20, 2016

Battling $50 billion Yukos awards on two fronts, Russia focuses on claimants’ alleged fraud and linguistic analysis of tribunal assistant’s alleged role in drafting awards Nov 3, 2015

In-Depth: Reviewing Russia’s arguments for setting aside $50 billion Yukos awards Mar 5, 2015

JURISDICTION: arbitrators say tax exemption not self-judging, and referral by Yukos to local authorities would be futile; legality duty on investors proves toothless due to identity-change Jul 31, 2014

LIABILITY: in Yukos arbitration, tribunal dwells on disproportionate nature of measures, and sees no need to look at FET claim Jul 31, 2014

DAMAGES: In Yukos arbitration, ECT tribunal rejected DCF valuation, and opts for “comparable companies” method Jul 31, 2014

Russia ordered to pay US$50 bil to former Yukos majority shareholders; as in Oxy case, Fortier-chaired tribunal reduces damages due to investor’s misbehaviour Jul 28, 2014

Despite Khodorkovsky release, majority owners of Yukos have no plans to drop $113 billion arbitration claim against Russian Federation as a final ruling looms Dec 24, 2013

Jurisdiction upheld in massive claim against Russia, but decision remains under wraps; ECHR to hear claim by Yukos in January Dec 21, 2009