Annulment and Court Review of Awards

Print Send a summary of this page to someone via email.

Recent articles

  German Court rejects Slovak Republic’s suggestion that arbitrators were wrong to find jurisdiction over intra-EU investment treaty dispute
  Arbitral victory in Yukos case slowly unraveling as U.S. hedge fund declines to spend more money defending arbitral award from Russian attack
  ANALYSIS: Amidst thicket of Thai and Indonesian investment laws, confusion as to admission requirements found in some Southeast Asian investment treaties
  ICSID Round-Up: Argentina bondholders tribunal reconstituted, Hungary tribunal picked, and two new annulment panels chosen
  U.S. Appeals Court rules that lower court should not have stayed award enforcement proceedings in Belize dispute
  ANALYSIS: Latest split amongst ICSID arbitrators over Argentina’s necessity defense reflects wider chasm; role of “state practice” in treaty interpretation also studied
  U.S. Court tears up $185+ Million award due to failure of arbitrators to respect treaty’s call for 18 months of local litigation in Argentina
  Panels selected in ICSID matters involving Moldova, Egypt, and the Central African Republic
  BRIEFLY NOTED: Arbitrator resigns after sharp dissent in ICSID case; Peru and Argentina each move to annul awards at ICSID
  ICSID Round-up: Arbitrators named in cases against Poland, Kazakhstan and Egypt; annulment committee picked in Ukraine case
  ICSID to prepare “background paper” on annulment process, following request by Philippines; German investor criticizes effort by Philippines
  Mexico loses bid to set aside NAFTA arbitration award in Canadian appeals court
  Thailand comes out swinging in fight over non-payment of BIT arbitral award; government alleges that minority shareholder in highway project had contract obligation to not sue under treaty
  Challenge to member of ICSID ad-hoc committee presiding in Panama energy dispute is rejected by his colleagues
  As ICSID member-states prepare to convene for annual meeting, functioning of annulment process is put on the agenda
  Arbitral award in Argentine financial crisis case will stand; government obliged to pay modest sum to U.S. insurance company
  Togo fails to overturn ICSID arbitral award; damages owed to French electricity investors amount to 12% of state revenue
  Efforts to set-aside intra-EU BIT award likely to be abandoned, as government claims victory in arbitration
  Tribunal picked to hear Peruvian electricity dispute; Ukrainian radio tenders case moves to annulment phase
  ANALYSIS: In battle over $100 Million award, spotlight shifts to opaque state-to-state arbitration over treaty meaning
  Final damages ruling comes in much lower than Chevron had hoped, but Ecuador still adamant that arbitrators overstepped their bounds in substituting for local courts
  ICSID panelists named in annulment cases involving El Salvador and Egypt, and in arbitration arising out of Niger airport services dispute
  ICSID annulment proceeding is discontinued in Jordan construction case, as third-party funding is again flagged
  Ecuador initiates unusual state-to-state arbitration against United States in bid to clarify scope of investment treaty obligation
  Lithuania denies access to arbitral award rendered in arbitration brought by Russian entity
  New panel picked to hear resubmitted claim by Enron creditors against Argentina
  Investor in Egypt moves to annul unfavourable arbitral award in dispute over canceled airport construction project
  Unpublished discussion paper gives overview of European Commission trade department's recent thinking on foreign investment dispute settlement
  ICSID annulment case discontinued and investor ordered to reimburse government for its legal costs; panel affirms that third-party funding should not affect costs recovery
  ANALYSIS: Tribunal ruling in GEA v Ukraine offers contrast to earlier ICSID arbitration where non-enforcement of arbitral award was at issue